Description of Mechanical Systems by the Use of Quadripole Parameters
Harald Kammerer
The author expects that this worksheet will only be used for teaching and educational purposes and not for commercial profit without contacting the author for a licensed agreement.
The following numerical values are only academic examples and have no reference to real structures.
Motivation
Let's consider a mechanical device defined with an input gate and an output gate. At the input gate there are two values of the force and the velocity . At the output gate there are the two values of the force and the velocity . So we have all in all two gates and four items. This system can be described in the equivalent manner as an electrical quadripole. So we call this system a mechanical quadripole. Such a quadripole is shown in Figure 1.
For example in [2] there is some more detailed description of this method. Here we will give a first introduction in this theory.
We can consider it as a black box. It is not important of what the device consists. It is only important how it works. In this worksheet we will see how we can use this method to work with some special dynamical systems. But first we have to give some conditions for the mechanical systems. Perhaps not all of the following conditions are necessary, but they will help to understand this idea.
We define a helpful procedure first. This procedure is used in the following to convert complex values into the standard form .
Conditions
At first we assume that all motions are harmonic vibrations. All other kind of motions must be analyzed by use of a Fourier transformation. Further, the devices should be a straight line. There is only one input gate and one output gate. That means for example that no rocking of the foundation is possible. We consider devices with linearly dependantence between the force and the displacement, velocity or the acceleration is possible. For example no Duffing device is considered.
All the following relations are defined by use of the angular frequency . For practical use it is usual to consider the frequency . The relation between and is
Description of the motion
Every motion, especially every harmonic vibration, can be described by the displacement, the velocity or the acceleration. Of course there are some constants of integration, but in our consideration they are not important. We describe here the motion by the velocity, as shown in Figure 1. The velocity should be given as a harmonic vibration in complex notation.
The displacement is can be integrated from the velocity
And the acceleration is derived from the velocity
Here we express the displacement and the acceleration by the velocity. This allows us to generate a formalism to describe any device. For example the displacement and acceleration are expressed by the velocity
Impedance
We have assumed that the forces are linearly dependant on the displacement, velocity or the acceleration. Additionally we assumed that only harmonic vibrations are considered. This means that we can write for the relation between force and velocity
or
R is called the impedance of a device or a structure.
Impedances of Standard Devices
Let's consider some typical devices and their impedances.
Spring
First consider the spring in Figure 2.
Figure 2
The displacement at the upper end of the spring should be given by , the velocity is .
The force which is neededed to produce this displacement is
For the impedance of the spring we get
Damper
We repeat the same consideration for a viscous damper.
Figure 3
The displacement and the velocity are again given by and .
The Force on the damper is now
Mass
The third standard device is a rigid body with mass m.
Figure 4
Now we define the displacement and the velocity again with and . Additionally we use now the acceleration .
The force which is needed to move the body is
Elastic Half-Space
At last we give the Impedance for an elastic half-space as an example as shown in Figure 5.
Figure 5
Such an elastic half-space is used to describe the soil under a foundation. It is not so easy to deduce the impedance of this half-space. It is given for example in [1] by
In this relation is the shear modulus, is the Poisson's ratio and is the specific mass of the soil. is the angular frequency of the harmonic vibration. is the radius of the area where the force is acting.
Quadripole Parameters
In practice two different ways to describe a quadripole as shown in Figure 1 are common. The first form is the chain form, the second is the impedance form.
Chain Form
In this form we describe the values of the input gate dependent on the values of the output gate:
Due to the condition that all forces are linearly dependantent on the displacement, velocity or the acceleration and the condition that we only consider harmonic vibrations, it follows
The values , , and are called the quadripole parameter of the chain form.
In matrix form we can write
Impedance Form
In this form we describe all forces dependent on the velocities:
Same as in the chain form, this yields
The values , , and are called the quadripole parameter of the impedance form.
In this worksheet we use the impedance form only as an aid. So when we say "quadripole parameter" we mean the quadripole parameter of the chain form.
Conversion
Of course both forms can be converted to the other. It is practical to make this by use of procedures.
Calculate the quadripole parameter of the impedance form from the quadripole parameter of the chain form (chain form -> impedance form)
Calculate the quadripole parameter of the chain form from the quadripole parameter of the impedance form (impedance form -> chain form)
Quadripole Parameter of Standard Devices
Now we will give the quadripole parameter for some typical devices.
First we consider the spring shown in Figure 6
Figure 6
To get the quadripole parameter we first consider the forces and . To fulfill the condition for the equilibrium, the forces must be equal.
Next we know that the spring will be stretched by
With the displacement on the input gate we get
and on the output gate
For the relation between the stretching of the spring and the force we assume linearly dependence
This yields for the relation between the force and the velocities at the input gate and the output gate
or after rearrangement
Now we have the four quadripole parameter for the matrix
In matrix form we get
Next consider the damper in Figure 7.
Figure 7
The situation is equivalent to that for the spring. To fulfill the equilibrium condition, and must be equal.
The damper is stretched by
and the difference of the velocities on both sides is
For the relation between the relative velocity and the damping force we assume linearity
After rearrangement we get
As the last standard device, we consider the rigid body in Figure 8.
Figure 8
for a rigid body, the displacement and the velocity at the input gate and at the output gate are the same.
In the equilibrium condition, we have to consider the inertia
We replace the acceleration by the velocity and get
Now we have the four quadripole parameters for the matrix
Quadripole Parameter of a Vibration Source
In some structures the vibration source is a very complex system that cannot easily be described analytically. But sometimes the impedance of the vibration source is known, for example from the constructer of the machine.
Figure 9
For such a structure, we assume that the force which will be transmitted to the connected device at the output gate 1 can be measured. Additionally we assume that the structure is rigid. So we know that
.
The force that generates the vibration is then
In matrix form this yields
The matrix of the quadripole parameter is then
Combination of Standard Devices
A lot of different devices can be described by combinations of the standard devices spring, damper and mass. There are two principal ways to combine two devices.
Serial Connection
First the devices can be combined as a chain one behind the other as shown in Figure 10.
Figure 10
This is called a serial connection.We have two devices.
The device 1 has the input gate and the output gate .
At the same time is the input gate of the device 2 and is the output gate of device 2.
So we get the relations
with the quadripole parameter of device 1 and of device 2. Joining both equations yields
The matrix of the quadripole parameter of the serial connection of two devices is the product of the matrices of the quadripole parameter of both single devices.
This function is defined in the following procedure for several serial connected devices.
Parallel Connection
Now we consider the situation of two devices combined in parallel as shown in Figure 11.
Figure 11
This is called a parallel connection. Again we have two devices. But now the situation is a bit more complicated.
Device 1 has the input gate and the output gate .
Device 2 has the input gate and the output gate .
At last ,the input gate of the total device should be and the output gate .
The velocities at the input gate must all be equal. That means and . The same is valid for the output gate: and
The force on both gates of the parallel connection is the sum of the forces at all single devices. That means and .
Now we use the impedance form of our quadripoles. We can use the above defined procedure chain2impedance to convert the quadripole parameter of the chain form and into the quadripole parameter of the impedance form and .
With this we can write
Remember that all velocities at the input gate are the same, and the same holds at the output gate. Combination of theses equations yields
with the matrix of the quadripole parameter of the impedance form of the total device as the sum of the matrices of the quadripole parameter of the impedance form of all the single devices
Finally we get the quadripole parameter of the chain form of the total device by convert ing the quadripole parameter of the impedance form by use of the procedure impedance2chain.
This process is also defined in the following procedure for several parallel connected devices.
Some typical combinations of standard devices
There are several combination of the above defined standard devices often used in practice. Some of them are shown here.
KELVIN-VOIGT Model
This model is used to describe visco-elastic devices as parallel connection of an ideal elastic spring with an ideal viscous damper as shown in Figure 12
Figure 12
The quadripole parameters of this model are calculated by use of the procedure parallelconnection.
The input parameters for this procedure are the matrices of the quadripole parameter of the damper
and the spring
The matrix of the quadripole parameter of the KELVIN-VOIGT model is consequently
Additionally we will consider the impedance of such a device. This can be derived different ways. First we can consider the quadripole parameter for the case that the velocity at the output gate is =0.
We will not do this here but we consider the relation between the force and the velocity. The force which passes through the KELVIN-VOIGT model is given by
And the impedance is the quotient of the force and the velocity
We see this is the sum of the impedances of the two single devices.
MAXWELL Model
This is another model which is used to describe viscous elastic devices. Here an ideal elastic spring and an ideal viscous damper are connected as a chain in series as shown in Figure 13
Figure 13
Such a device is only able to transmit dynamic forces.
The quadripole parameter of this model are calculated by use of the procedure serialconnection.
The input parameters for this procedure are again the matrices of the quadripole parameter of the damper
The matrix of the quadripole parameter of the MAXWELL model is consequently
Again we will also consider the impedance of such a device. We assume for this that the velocity on the output gate of this device is . The force must go directly through the device. That means that the force on the spring and the force on the damper are eqaul: and . The velocity of the damper is then given by
The displacement of the spring is
Because we assume harmonic motion, we get for the velocity in the spring
The velocity at the input gate of the total device is the sum of the single velocities
Spring-Damper-Mass-System
Next we consider how a simple spring-damper-mass-system is typically used to describe the simplest structural dynamic system as a single-degree-of-freedom system. This system is shown in Figure 14
Figure 14
This model is the parallel connection of a spring and a damper and these two devices together in series with the mass. The above formalism yields the following for the total device
The impedance of this device can be deduced when we assume that the velocity at gate 2 must be 0
From the definition of the quadripole parameter we know the relation
or written for this special case as two equations
The solution of this two equations yields the force at the output gate and the velocity at the input gate , both dependent on the force at the input gate .
At last we calculate the relation between the force and the velocity at the input gate to get the impedance
4-Parametrical MAXWELL Model
At last we consider a model which is composed by four single standard devices as shown in Figure 15
Figure 15
This model is the parallel connection of two MAXWELL models, which are themselves serial connections of a spring and a damper. The damper on the left line has damping resistance , the spring on the left line has stiffness . The damper and the spring on the right line have the damping resistance and the stiffness . We use the information about the MAXWELL model for the two partial devices on the left and on the right line to get the matrices of the quadripole parameter
The matrix of the quadripole parameter for the total device is now easy to calculate as a parallel connection of and
The impedance of this device is the sum of the impedance of the MAXWELL device on the left line and that on the right line, same as in the parallel connection of a damper with a spring
Example
Now we will consider an example. As shown in Figure 16 we have a a special machine as the source of the vibration. All values here and in the following are given in N, m, kg and s. Consequently the impedances are given in Ns/m. Please note: These numerical values are academic examples only.
Figure 16
We have the input gate given by
and the output gate given by
The impedance of the source shall be given by its real part
and its imaginary part
So the impedance is
Let's consider graphs of these functions.
Most of the time, the absolute value is the most interesting, so we draw it with a thick line.
The argument of this function is shown in the next picture
The matrix of the quadripole parameter of the vibration source follows from above
Next we consider the foundation, the recipient. We assume the following numerical values and use the definition for the elastic half-space defined above.
The impedance of the recipient is then
This result is best shown graphically. The first picture shows the real part, the imaginary part and the absolute value.
The next picture shows the angle between the real part and the imaginary part of the impedance.
Now we consider some devices which are arranged between the machine and the soil for vibration control. Here we assume that the excitation force for all the following examples is identical. That means that there is no feedback interaction from the structure to the source of the excitation. Otherwise this problem would be much more complicated and not so easily solved without more details about the excitation.
Rigid Connection
Rigid connection means that the machine stands on the ground without any device. So we have the relation
That means for the matrix of the quadripole parameter
The total structure is a serial connection of the source with a rigid connection.
Of course this is the same as the matrix of the quadripole parameter of the source itself. The relation between the values of the input gate , and the values at the output gate , is
This yields for the values of the output gate
This means
At last we use our information about the impedance of the output gate
The solution of this equation yields the velocity at the input gate dependent on the force at the input gate
For the velocity on the output gate we get
We use this derivation later again, so it makes sense to define this in form of a procedure
We show the result for the ground velocity graphically
Vibration Isolation by a Spring
Next we consider the situation that a spring is set between the machine and the ground . Then we have the matrix of the quadripole parameter of the spring with the stiffness
and the matrix of the quadripole parameter of the serial connection of the vibration source and the spring
We get the velocity at the output gate by use of the above defined procedure
The most important point is now the comparison between the velocity in the case of the rigid position of the machine on the ground with the velocity with the spring between machine and ground.
In blue, the velocity of the case of the rigid connection is displayed.
Most interesting is normally the question, what is the relation between the absolute value of the velocity at the output gate in case of the rigid support and the isolated support by use of a spring. This is usually shown in a special logarithmic scale. For details please see the literature, for example [1]. We calculate the quotient between the velocity of the ground in case of rigid connection and that in case of supporting by use of any device, here the spring. Then we have to calculate the logarithm and multiply by 20. This result has no physical dimension. It is called the insertion loss for the inserted device. To emphasize this kind of presentation, we use the pseudo dimension dB (decibel). Although this property belongs to the inserted device, it depends on the impedance of the vibration source and the impedance of the recipient, here the ground. Strictly speaking, it is not possible to give the insertion loss of a pure device but only in combination with its use.
Here we calculate the insertion loss of the spring.
Vibration Isolation by a Damper
Next we consider the situation that a damper is set between the machine and the ground . Of course this idea is more theoretically interesting, because the damper itself cannot carry the static load of a machine. In reality there must be some device that can do that.
We have the matrix of the quadripole parameter of the damper with the damping residence
and the matrix of the quadripole parameter of the serial connection of the vibration source and the damper
The following diagram shows the ground velocities for all the previously considered situations
Again we calculate the insertion loss of the damper
It seems that the damper, especially in the range of lower frequencies, gives the better reduction of the vibration. Only for higher frequencies, in this example from about 50 Hz, the spring support yields a higher insertion loss than the spring. Unfortunately the damper itself cannot carry the static load, so we need something as a spring. Let's consider what happens when we use a combination of a spring and a damper.
Vibration Isolation by a KELVIN-VOIGT Device
Next we consider the situation that a combination of a spring and a damper according the KELVIN-VOIGT model is set between the machine and the ground . Then we have the matrix of the quadripole parameter of the device with the spring stiffness and the damping residence .
and the matrix of the quadripole parameter of the serial connection of the vibration source and the KELVIN-VOIGT device is
We get again the velocity at the output gate by use of the above defined procedure
The following diagram shows the ground velocities
Again we calculate the insertion loss of the device
As expected this solution is somewhere between the support by a spring and the support by a damper. The advantage of the KELVIN-VOIGT device against the single spring is the fact that there is not so big an incursion in the insertion loss.
Vibration Isolation by a MAXWELL Device
Next we consider the situation that a combination of a spring and a damper according the MAXWELL model with the spring stiffness and the damping residence is set between the machine and the ground . As with the single damper, this device cannot carry static loads and is not capable for practical use of supporting a machine.
We have the matrix of the quadripole parameter of the device
The velocity at the output gate is now
We calculate the insertion loss of the device
Up to now this model is the best one for elimating ground vibrations. Unfortunately it cannot be used because it cannot carry static loads.
Vibration Isolation by Double Spring Device with one Damper
Next we consider the situation that a combination of a spring, an additional mass and a second spring in series and parallel to this damper is set between the machine and the ground . This device is shown in Figure 17.
Figure 17
The spring stiffness shall be
and the damping resistance is again .
The mass shall be
The matrices of the single quadripole parameter are
first spring:
mass
second spring
damper
The matrix of the quadripole parameter of the serial connection of the spring, the mass and the second spring is
And the parallel connection from this with the damper is
This yields with the source in series
The velocity at the output gate is
The following diagram shows the ground velocities for all the up to now situations
This devise is not so easy to classify, because to do this we must consider a lot of different combinations of spring stiffness, damping resistances and Additionally masses. The combination we used in this example seems not to be a very good solution.
Vibration Isolation by Double Spring-Damper Device
Next we consider the situation that a combination of a KELVIN-VOIGT device, an additional mass and a second KELVIN-VOIGT device in series is set between the machine and the ground as shown in Figure 18.
Figure 18
and the damping resistance is
first KELVIN-VOIGT device:
second KELVIN-VOIGT device
The matrix of the quadripole parameter of the serial connection of the fist KELVIN-VOIGT device, mass and the second KELVIN-VOIGT device is
Consider that this device has the same additional mass as the device above. The only difference between both models is the fact that the damper here is divided in two, just as the spring, so the motion of the additional mass is directly damped in this model. The advantage is easy to see in the insertion loss. We get with this device for frequencies higher than about 60 Hz the best values for the insertion loss. Such devices are often used for the isolation of machines in very sensitive areas, for example, in ships. The vibration of the motor of a ship otherwise can easily be transmitted through all the ship.
But once again: Remember that all numerical values are only academic examples. Real devises have more complicated properties than we can show here. For exdample, the spring itself is a mass, every real damper has a certain stiffness, and I don't believe that one can find in reality a vibration source with such a simple form of the impedancethe as described here .
Literature
[1] M. Heckl, H.A. Mller, Taschenbuch der Technischen Akustik, p. 571-595, Springer-Verlag, 2nd Edition, Berlin 1994
[2] E. Seidel, Wirksamkeit von Konstruktionen zur Schwingungs- und Krperschalldmmung in Maschinen und Gerten, Schriftenreihe der Bundesanstalt fr Arbeitsschutz und Arbeitsmedizin, Dortmund/Berlin 1999